Why is this beach so highly rated? Perhaps by those who are not willing to venture 2-5 miles in any direction to find a better beach.
Although this beach is beautiful, it's difficult to give it more than 2 stars when there are so many other beaches on the island that are even better. This one tends to be crowded with children and tourists.
On the plus side, there is a shallow area that is sectioned off and offers a great view of Diamond Head.
If you don't have children and have access to a bike, scooter, car, or bus pass, do yourself a favor and explore other beaches. However, if you're looking for a beach near Burger King or the Marriott hotel, then this one may be for you.
To clarify, if this were a beach in Canada, it would be rated a 9/10, but you're in Hawaii, so go find an amazing beach!